Top 14 SAT® and ACT® Myths Debunked: An Essential Guide for Test-Prep Tutors

Standardized tests like the ACT® and SAT® play a crucial role in the college admissions process.

They are more than just graduation requirements or part of a student’s college application profile. High schools and colleges use these test scores in various ways, such as for course and level placement, improving curricula, and providing better academic advising.

For colleges, the ACT® and SAT® are reliable metrics for comparing and contrasting applicants, ensuring that admitted students meet their academic standards and are more likely to succeed in their programs.

Despite their importance, there are many myths and misconceptions about the SAT® and ACT® that persist and often lead high school students off track. These misconceptions can affect how students prepare for these tests, ultimately impacting their performance and future academic and career prospects.

Let’s take a look at the most common false claims about these standardized tests and clarify these common misunderstandings so that we, as test-prep professionals, can better explain the incentives for taking the ACT® and/or SAT® to our clients and their families.

By debunking these myths, we can better guide our students toward effective preparation strategies, helping them achieve their best possible scores so they can reach their goals.

Myth #1: Test-Optional Policies Mean Test Scores Don’t Matter

Test-optional policies allow students to decide whether to submit SAT® or ACT® scores with their college applications. If scores are submitted, they will be considered; if not, the application is processed without them.

Test-Optional Schools Don’t Ignore Test Scores

Importance of Strong Test Scores - Even for Test-Optional Schools

Despite some schools’ test-optional policies, strong test scores remain valuable. They provide a reliable comparison point in admissions and can distinguish students in a competitive applicant pool.

Colleges also use these scores for course placement and academic advising, ensuring students are matched with appropriate classes.

Test Scores Can Enhance College Applications

Submitting strong SAT® or ACT® scores can significantly enhance a college application. Test scores offer an additional measure to differentiate between similar applicants and demonstrate academic readiness. They provide consistent and objective evidence of a student's abilities.

While test-optional policies offer flexibility, submitting strong test scores can improve a student's chances of admission and provide invaluable information for colleges.

If your clients are on the fence about sending their scores to test-optional or test-flexible schools, encourage them to do so.

For a look at some of the latest schools to reinstate standardized testing mandates, check out:

Myth #2: Colleges Only Accept Either the ACT® or SAT®, Not Both

Contrary to popular belief, most colleges and universities in the U.S. accept both the ACT® and SAT®. This allows students the flexibility to choose the test that best matches their strengths and test-taking styles, providing multiple pathways to demonstrate their academic readiness.

How Students Can Choose Which Test Suits Them Better

Help your clients decide which test is the right fit for their personal strengths. Choosing between the ACT® and SAT® involves evaluating several factors:

1. Test Timing and Pacing: The key differences are really between the testing format and structure chosen (i.e., Digital SAT® compared to the Digital ACT® or paper-and-pencil ACT®). In general:

ACT®: Faster pace, less time per question. Suitable for quick readers.
SAT®: More time per question. Better for a methodical approach.

2. Math and Calculator Use:

ACT®: Calculator allowed on all ACT® math questions; all questions are multiple-choice.
SAT®: Calculators are allowed on the entire test; SAT® Math questions are short and straightforward, however some require fill-in answers.

3. Analytical and Science Skills:

ACT®: Includes a Science section focused on data interpretation and analysis.
SAT®: Analytical skills integrated into Reading & Writing and Math sections.

4. Essay Writing and Argumentation:

SAT®: The SAT® no longer has an essay section.
ACT®: The optional writing section involves taking and defending a position.

Students should take practice tests for both tests to see which one they perform better on and feel more comfortable with so they can choose the test that best aligns with their strengths and maximizes their chances of success.

Myth #3: The ACT® is Easier than the SAT®

A common misconception is that one of these tests is easier than the other—typically that the ACT® is easier than the SAT®—but that is simply not true.

We outlined the key differences between the ACT® and SAT® above. Setting aside their differences, both tests are designed to assess similar skills and knowledge—even if they do so in different ways.

Each test has its own unique format and poses different challenges for every test taker; therefore, the notion that the ACT® is universally easier than the SAT® (or vice versa) is a myth.

Practice Tests Can Determine Which Test Suits the Student Better

Taking practice tests for both the ACT® and SAT® is pivotal for determining which test aligns best with a student's strengths and test-taking style. Practice tests:

1. Identify Strengths and Weaknesses: Practice tests help students identify which test’s format and question types they handle better.

2. Simulate Test Conditions: Practicing under timed conditions using real tests can reveal how a student manages the pacing of each test.

Make Your Practice ACT® & SAT® Tests Feel like the Real Thing

3. Informed Decision: Comparing practice test scores allows students to make a better-informed decision about which test to focus on to maximize their performance.

Encouraging your students to take practice tests for both the ACT® and SAT® ensures they choose the test that best suits their abilities, leading to better overall performance and higher scores.

Facilitating this process helps students make strategic decisions that align with their strengths, ultimately enhancing their college admissions prospects.

Myth #4: Optimal Timing for Taking the Tests

Many students believe they should wait until late Junior year to take the SAT® or ACT®. This idea can limit their opportunities to achieve their best possible scores. Waiting until the last minute can lead to unnecessary stress and leave little room for improvement if initial scores are not as high as hoped.

Is your client ready? 4 Telltale Signs That Your Client's Ready to Take the Real Test.

Advantages of Taking the Tests Earlier

Taking the SAT® or ACT® earlier in Junior year or even in Sophomore year has several benefits:

1. Early Benchmarking: Early testing helps establish a baseline score. This allows students to identify their strengths and weaknesses and plenty of time to tweak and tailor their preparation accordingly.

2. Reduced Stress: Taking the test early can alleviate the pressure of Senior year, which is often filled with college applications, extracurricular activities, and other responsibilities.

3. Multiple Attempts: Testing early gives students the flexibility to retake the test multiple times. There is no limit on how many times a student can test.

Furthermore, Research shows that students often improve their scores with each attempt, as they become more familiar with the test format and content.

Multiple Attempts and Improvement Over Time

1. Refinement of Strategies: With each test attempt, students can refine their test-taking strategies. They learn from their mistakes and adjust their approach, leading to better performance.

2. Mastery of Content: Continuous preparation over time allows for a deeper understanding and mastery of test content. Students can gradually build their knowledge and skills, which is crucial for achieving higher scores.

3. Improved Confidence: Multiple attempts help build confidence. As students see their scores improve, they become more assured in their abilities, reducing anxiety on test day.

By encouraging students to take the SAT® or ACT® early and providing opportunities for multiple attempts, we can help our clients maximize their potential and achieve their best possible scores.

Early testing, combined with ongoing preparation and practice, ensures students are well-prepared and confident when it comes time to submit their scores to colleges.

Myth #5: The ACT® Writing Section is Optional, So It’s Not Important

The ACT® Writing Test, while optional, is a valuable component for students applying to specific types of colleges, such as liberal arts institutions. These schools often emphasize strong writing and communication skills as part of their educational philosophy.

Colleges use these writing scores to gauge a student's ability to construct well-organized, persuasive essays. This skill is crucial in higher education, where effective written communication is essential for success. Demonstrating proficiency in writing through the ACT® Writing Test can help showcase a student’s readiness for the rigorous writing demands of college-level coursework.

ACT® Essay Advice

1. Understand the Task: The ACT® Writing Test requires students to read a series of short introductory statements on a given topic, develop a persuasive thesis, and compose a clear, well-structured essay. Students should focus on crafting an argument using their own original ideas rather than analyzing a pre-selected text.

2. Develop a Strong Thesis: The thesis should be clear and take a definitive stance on the issue presented in the prompt. They must ensure their argument is logical and supported by relevant examples and reasoning.

3. Stay Organized: The structure of the essay should have a clear introduction, body paragraphs, and a conclusion. Each paragraph should have a main point supporting the thesis and include evidence or examples.

4. Use Effective Language: Students should employ a formal, academic tone and avoid casual language. They must demonstrate their ability to use varied sentence structures and a rich vocabulary.

5. Practice Timed Writing:

Test takers have 40 minutes to complete the ACT® Writing Test, so students should practice writing essays within this time frame.
Encourage them to time themselves to ensure they can plan, write, and revise their essay effectively within the allotted time.

By opting to take the ACT® Writing Test, students can provide a more comprehensive picture of their academic abilities to prospective colleges, particularly those that value strong writing skills.

It’s important to encourage your students to consider taking the Writing Test as a way to enhance their applications and stand out in the competitive admissions process.

Myth #6: Only Students With Strong Science Skills Can Ace The ACT®

One of the most common misunderstandings about the ACT® is that students need to have strong science skills to do well on the Science section.

In reality, the ACT® Science Test is more about interpreting and evaluating data than recalling specific scientific knowledge. The Science section covers topics like biology, chemistry, physics, and earth science, but the focus is on applying scientific skills, particularly data analysis, rather than memorizing facts.

Students are required to read and analyze data presented in various forms, including graphs, tables, illustrations, and written passages. The questions test their ability to understand experimental setups, identify patterns, and draw conclusions from the data presented.

Therefore, even students who might not excel in science classes can perform well on the ACT® Science section by honing their data interpretation and a few non-science skills like critical reading, using context clues, and time management.

Tips for Approaching the ACT® Science Section

1. Find the Story in the Data:

Understand that data is about patterns, not just numbers. Look for trends and meaningful observations in the data presented.
Practice interpreting different data formats and identifying key conclusions. For example, know how to spot major outliers or trends across multiple trials.

2. Understand Variables and Relationships:

Get comfortable with the language of scientific experimentation, particularly the difference between independent and dependent variables.
Recognize how these variables are typically represented in graphs (e.g., independent variables on the x-axis and dependent variables on the y-axis).

3. Practice Data Interpretation:

Engage with a variety of data formats, both in isolation and in combination. Use practice materials that include graphs, tables, and figures to build familiarity.
Simulate test conditions by practicing with time constraints and without a calculator, as calculators are not permitted on the ACT® Science Test.

4. Analyze Cause and Effect:

Focus on understanding cause-and-effect relationships in scientific experiments. This often involves identifying how changes in the independent variable affect the dependent variable.
Practice interpreting graphs and other visual data representations to quickly grasp these relationships.

5. Replace Variables with Constants: If scientific jargon becomes confusing, replace variables with algebraic constants (like x or y) to simplify the data. This can make it easier to identify relationships and draw conclusions.

By focusing on these data interpretation skills, students can excel in the ACT® Science section, regardless of their background in specific science subjects. Emphasizing these strategies during practice can help students build the confidence and skills needed to achieve high scores on this section.

Myth #7: The ACT® and SAT® are only IQ Tests

Although the SAT® was originally designed as an IQ test, standardized testing has advanced since its conception in 1926 to play a significant role in various meaningful aspects of modern education.

Today, standardized tests are more than just a score; they assess specific academic skills, focusing on a student’s ability to apply learned knowledge to solve problems and analyze data.

The ACT® and SAT® are designed to be objective, ensuring a fair assessment of each student’s academic abilities, free from human bias.

Test-Taking Strategies and Prep

1. Problem-Solving Skills: The ACT® and SAT® require critical thinking and problem-solving. Students must determine relevant information and apply it to find solutions, akin to real-world problem-solving scenarios.

2. Time Management and Emotional Self-Management: Both tests are timed, so students must work efficiently, manage their time, prioritize questions, and stay calm under pressure. These skills are crucial for the test and future challenges.

3. Resiliency: Preparing for these tests builds resilience as students learn to persist through setbacks. This tenacity is valuable for academic, personal, and professional challenges.

4. Practical Skills: The ACT® and SAT® assess functional skills like reading comprehension, grammar, and math, which are useful in everyday life.

5. Academic Aptitude and Achievement: These tests provide colleges with a quick metric to evaluate a student’s readiness for college-level coursework, making them essential for college admissions.

The ACT® and SAT® are not IQ tests but comprehensive assessments of academic skills and readiness for college. They provide a fair and unbiased measure of a student's abilities.

Myth #8: It Is Best To Leave Unknown Test Questions Blank

It’s a widespread belief that it’s better to leave unknown test questions blank. However, the ACT® and SAT® are designed in a way that encourages guessing rather than leaving answers blank. The key is to understand the scoring system and the benefits of making an educated guess.

Why It’s Better to Guess

1. No Penalty for Wrong Answers:

The ACT® has no penalty for incorrect answers. This means that students only earn points for correct answers and do not lose points for wrong ones. Leaving a question blank results in zero points, whereas a guess, even if incorrect, does not negatively impact the score.
Similarly, the SAT® also has no penalty for incorrect answers. Students gain points for correct answers but do not lose points for wrong guesses, making it advantageous to attempt every question.

2. Maximizing Your Score: By guessing, students increase their chances of getting some answers correct. Statistically, making an educated guess is better than leaving a question unanswered. Even if a student has no idea about the correct answer, guessing still provides a 25% chance of choosing the right option in a four-choice question.

3. Elimination Strategy: Encourage students to use the process of elimination. If they can narrow down the choices to two or three options, their chances of guessing correctly improve significantly. This strategy increases the likelihood of earning more points.

4. Time Management: Remind your students to manage their time effectively during the test. If they encounter a difficult question, it’s better to make a quick guess and move on, rather than spending too much time on one question and potentially missing out on easier questions later.

Have more time at the end of a section? Here’s how test takers can use that time wisely.

By understanding the scoring systems of the ACT® and SAT®, students can see the clear advantage of guessing over leaving questions blank. Reinforce this strategy during practice tests to help students maintain the habit of guessing over skipping to improve their overall test performance.

Myth # 9: Test Scores are the Determinant in College Admissions

While strong test scores are an important component of college applications, it’s important to remind our clients that they are not the sole determinant of college admissions decisions.

Colleges and universities employ a holistic approach when evaluating applicants, considering multiple facets of a student's profile. This comprehensive assessment ensures that admissions decisions are based on a full picture of a student's abilities, achievements, and potential contributions to the campus community.

Other Factors That Colleges Consider Alongside Test Scores

1. Academic Performance:

GPA and Course Rigor: Colleges look at a student’s GPA and the rigor of their coursework. High grades in challenging courses demonstrate a student’s readiness for college-level work and commitment to academic excellence.
Class Rank: Class rank can provide context for a student’s academic achievements relative to their peers.

2. Extracurricular Activities:

Leadership and Involvement: Participation in clubs, sports, community service, and other extracurricular activities showcases a student’s leadership skills, passions, and ability to balance multiple responsibilities.
Unique Talents and Interests: Colleges value students who bring unique talents and interests, whether in the arts, athletics, or other areas.

3. Personal Essays:

Personal Statement: Essays allow students to share their personal stories, values, and aspirations. A compelling essay can provide insight into a student’s character, motivations, and how they might contribute to the college community.
Supplemental Essays: Some colleges require additional essays that delve into specific aspects of a student’s background or interests, allowing for a more nuanced evaluation.

Traditional and Nontraditional College Essays That Get Applicants Noticed

4. Letters of Recommendation: Letters of recommendation offer third-party perspectives on a student’s academic abilities, character, and potential. Strong recommendations can highlight qualities that are not evident from grades and test scores alone.

Tips for High-Quality Letters of Recommendation

5. Interviews: Some colleges conduct interviews as part of the admissions process. These interviews provide an opportunity for students to articulate their goals, experiences, and reasons for wanting to attend the institution.

6. Special Circumstances: Admissions officers consider the context in which a student has achieved their accomplishments, including socio-economic background, personal challenges, and unique life experiences. This ensures a fair evaluation of each applicant’s potential.

7. Demonstrated Interest: Demonstrated interest, such as visiting the campus, attending information sessions, and communicating with admissions officers, can indicate a student’s genuine interest in the institution and can be a positive factor in the admissions process.

By taking a holistic approach, colleges aim to admit well-rounded students who will thrive academically, contribute to the campus community, and bring diverse perspectives and talents.

It’s important to remind students that while test scores are significant, they are just one piece of the puzzle in the college admissions process. Encouraging students to excel in multiple areas can help them present a strong, comprehensive application.

Myth #10: Colleges Prefer One Test Over the Other

A common myth is that colleges prefer either the SAT® or the ACT®, but this is not the case.

The vast majority of colleges and universities in the United States accept scores from both tests and do not favor one over the other.

Admissions officers are more concerned with how well a student performs on the chosen test rather than which test they take.

Students need to choose the test that best aligns with their strengths and test-taking style. By choosing the test that most aligns with their individual strengths, students can optimize their performance and increase their chances of achieving a high score.

Myth #11: Only College-Bound Students Need to Take the ACT® or SAT®

Even though the ACT® and SAT® are primarily associated with college admissions, their benefits extend far beyond this single purpose. These tests offer a range of advantages that can be valuable for all students, regardless of their post-high school plans.

Taking the ACT® or SAT® helps develop essential skills such as critical thinking, problem-solving, time management, and resilience, which are beneficial in various aspects of life and career.

Test Scores Can Open Opportunities Beyond College Admissions

1. Scholarships and Financial Aid: Many scholarship programs and financial aid opportunities require ACT® or SAT® scores as part of the application process. High scores can increase a student's eligibility for merit-based scholarships, which can significantly reduce the financial burden of higher education.

2. Career Opportunities: Certain employers and professional programs use standardized test scores to assess candidates' qualifications. For instance, some companies, particularly in finance and consulting, consider SAT® or ACT® scores during the hiring process as an indicator of analytical and problem-solving abilities.

3. Military Enlistment: The U.S. military may use ACT® or SAT® scores to determine eligibility for certain roles and training programs. High scores can enhance a candidate’s prospects for advanced positions and specialized training.

4. Skill Development: Preparing for and taking these tests helps students develop valuable skills that are applicable in various life scenarios. These skills include effective time management, the ability to work under pressure, and strong analytical capabilities, all of which are crucial in both academic and professional environments.

Graduation Requirements

In some school districts and states, taking the ACT® or SAT® is a graduation requirement. This policy ensures that all students, regardless of their post-secondary plans, have the opportunity to take a standardized test and benefit from the skills and knowledge assessed.

These requirements aim to provide a standardized measure of student achievement and readiness for life beyond high school, whether in college, vocational training, or the workforce.

Taking the ACT® or SAT® is not just for college-bound students. These tests offer a range of benefits. Additionally, in some cases, standardized test scores are necessary for high school graduation.

It’s important to communicate the broader advantages of these tests to our clients, helping students understand the value of strong test scores and encouraging our clients to prepare diligently, regardless of their future plans.

Myth #12: Students with High GPAs Don’t Need to Prepare for the ACT® and SAT®

A widespread belief is that students with high GPAs do not need to prepare for the ACT® or SAT®. However, academic success in school does not always translate directly to standardized test performance.

The ACT® and SAT® assess specific skills and knowledge areas that might not be fully covered in a high school curriculum. Therefore, preparation is crucial for all students, regardless of their GPA, to familiarize themselves with the test format, content, question types, and timing.

Examples of High GPA Students Benefiting from Test Prep

1. Bridging Gaps in Knowledge: Even top-performing students may have learning gaps or areas where they are less confident. Test prep can help identify and address these gaps, ensuring a more comprehensive understanding of the material covered on the ACT® and SAT®.

2. Enhancing Test-Taking Strategies: High-GPA students often excel in their coursework but might not have developed the specific strategies needed for standardized tests. Test prep provides these students with techniques for managing time, handling difficult questions, and maximizing their scores.

3. Improving Confidence and Reducing Anxiety: Test anxiety can affect any student, regardless of their GPA. Preparing for the ACT® and SAT® through practice tests and targeted study can build confidence and reduce anxiety, leading to better performance and less frustration on test day.

4. Achieving Competitive Scores for Scholarships and Admissions: Many scholarships and competitive college programs require exceptional test scores. Students with high GPAs who invest time and effort in test prep can significantly enhance their chances of securing these opportunities by achieving the highest possible scores.

5. Real-World Examples: Numerous high-achieving students have seen substantial benefits from dedicated test preparation.

For instance, a valedictorian might find that targeted SAT® prep helps boost their math score, making them a more competitive applicant for STEM programs. Similarly, a top student in humanities might improve their ACT® science section score through focused practice, broadening their college options.

Preparation for the ACT® and SAT® is essential for all students, including those with high GPAs. By investing in preparation, high-achieving students can ensure they perform to the best of their abilities and maximize their opportunities for scholarships and college admissions. Emphasizing the importance of preparation regardless of GPA can help all students achieve their full potential.

Myth #13: There is Limited Room for Improvement in Test Scores

A prevalent myth is that there is limited room for improvement in ACT® and SAT® scores, suggesting that students cannot significantly boost their scores through studying and test prep. This misconception overlooks the impact of dedicated practice and effective test-taking strategies.

In reality, many students achieve substantial score increases through focused preparation, targeted study, effective test-taking strategies, and repeated practice tests.

Take a look at this graph provided by ACT that shows just how dramatic score improvement can be with dedication and perseverance:

It’s crucial to encourage our clients to invest time and effort into their test prep. Through persistence and the right support, significant improvements are attainable.

Myth #14: Students Must Choose the ACT® OR the SAT®

A frequent misunderstanding is that students must choose between the ACT® and the SAT®, committing exclusively to one test for their college admissions process.

While traditionally, students and tutors focus their prep on one test, a dual-test strategy may be more advantageous. This approach provides flexibility and ensures that students have more opportunities to demonstrate their strengths, regardless of which test they ultimately sit for.

Benefits of a Two-Test Strategy

1. Broader Opportunities for Score Improvement: By preparing for both tests, students can apply score-improvement strategies across multiple attempts. This dual preparation allows students to leverage lessons learned from one test to enhance performance on the other, potentially leading to better overall results.

2. Adaptation to Different Test Formats: The ACT® and SAT® have distinct formats that cater to different strengths.

The ACT® requires a faster pace with a direct-question style and includes a dedicated science section.
The SAT® offers more time per question and integrates science and social studies content into its math and literacy sections.

Preparing for both tests helps students become adaptable and proficient in various testing environments.

How to Implement a Two-Test Strategy

1. Begin with Practice Tests: Have students complete practice tests for both the ACT® and SAT® to establish a baseline and identify their strengths and weaknesses. This initial assessment helps determine which test may be more suitable and where to focus improvement efforts.

2. Focus on the Ideal Test: First Use the results from practice tests and diagnostics to pair each student with the test that best highlights their existing skills. Focus initial preparation on this primary test to target the most significant areas for improvement.

3. Avoid Dual-Test Prepping: Once the primary test date has passed, shift the focus to preparing for the secondary test. Avoid preparing for both tests simultaneously, as this can be confusing and inefficient. Instead, concentrate on skill-building for the next scheduled test.

4. Address Common Weaknesses: Identify and prioritize areas of deficiency that are common to both tests. Investing time in high-frequency topics that appear on both the ACT® and SAT® can lead to score improvements on both exams. However, ensure that the context of skill-building is tailored to the specific test being prepared for at that time.

The idea that students must choose exclusively between the ACT® and SAT® is a myth. A two-test strategy offers greater flexibility, more opportunities for score improvement, and better adaptation to different test formats. By preparing for both tests sequentially and focusing on common areas of weakness, students can maximize their chances of achieving high scores.

Guiding students through a personalized dual-test approach can enhance their overall performance and college admissions prospects.

Debunking these common myths and sharing accurate information about the ACT®and SAT® with our clients is crucial for helping our students and their families navigate the college admissions process effectively.

By negating these misconceptions, we can provide well-rounded guidance that empowers our clients to make better-informed decisions, prepare thoroughly, and maximize their potential, ACT® and SAT®, opening doors to future opportunities.

Step into the Digital Age of SAT® Prep!

The SAT® has made the switch to all-digital testing—and so has Clear Choice Prep!

We’re ready to equip your tutoring business with top-tier, fully digital test-prep courses. Our white-label, all-digital, adaptive Digital SAT® practice tests come with accurate, algorithmic scoring, granting your tutors and students access to the vital data required for custom instruction and score enhancement.

Ready to upgrade your test prep? Schedule a free demo and experience it yourself!

Are You Ready to Digitize Your Test Prep?