Second Thoughts on Early Decision? How to Help Your Students Back Out Gracefully

Thinking about backing out of an Early Decision (ED) college commitment can feel like navigating a maze of emotions and consequences; understanding the right steps and potential repercussions is crucial for students grappling with second thoughts about their school choice.

Students who have applied for college through Early Decision (ED) and are now experiencing second thoughts may find the idea of backing out of their ED commitment intimidating and the process of canceling ED overwhelming.

While it is highly discouraged by schools, some circumstances can help students get out of the ED bind. This post provides essential guidance on how to help your clients understand the consequences of withdrawing from ED and how to navigate the process gracefully with clarity and confidence.

Remembering Why They Applied Early Decision

Before making any hasty decisions, applicants need to reflect on their reasons for choosing Early Decision in the first place.

Typically, students select ED because they are certain about their first-choice college, drawn by its academic programs, campus culture, and opportunities for personal and academic growth. Students who choose to apply for ED do so for a reason, and sometimes it helps to be reminded of those reasons.

Reminding your students of their initial excitement and goals may provide valuable perspective and could help them reaffirm their commitment to that school before they take on the process of requesting ED cancellation.

Potential Consequences of Canceling Early Decision

If your student feels confident that they need to withdraw their ED application or cancel an ED acceptance, they must understand that backtracking on an ED commitment is not a trivial issue, colleges take ED cancellations very seriously.

While it’s technically possible to withdraw from Early Decision, students should be aware of the consequences that may arise, especially if their reasons for backing out do not align with the college's acceptable conditions.

Here are the top three potential consequences:

1. Loss of Deposit: If students have already paid a deposit to secure their spot, they will most likely forfeit this money. An ED deposit typically ranges between $100 and $400; however, some schools require higher ED fees.

2. Reputation Issues: Colleges often communicate with each other, and withdrawing from an ED commitment without valid reasons may tarnish a student’s reputation and also reflect poorly on their high school.

3. Impact on Future Applications: Some colleges may choose to share information about students who withdraw from their ED commitments, which could hinder the students’ chances of acceptance at other institutions in the future.

Encourage your client to thoroughly investigate the specific consequences of canceling their early decision (ED) application by reviewing the school’s ED cancellation policy. This information is usually available on the school’s official website, particularly in the admissions section. If they require further clarification or have additional questions, suggest they reach out directly to the school’s admissions office for more detailed insights into the ED cancellation process.

Timing Matters: Withdrawing Before vs. After ED Acceptance

The timing of a student's Early Decision withdrawal can significantly impact the consequences they may face.

If they withdraw before acceptance…

  • Withdrawal is Possible: Students can back out before receiving their acceptance results. This option is often overlooked, but it is generally acceptable, especially if circumstances have changed—like finances.

  • Acceptable Reasons: Colleges are much more understanding of reasons for withdrawing from ED at this stage in the game; however, students should expect to be questioned regarding their reasons for ED cancellation.

If they withdraw after acceptance…

  • Limited Options: Once a student has been accepted, withdrawing from an ED commitment becomes much more complicated. Again, while ED is not legally binding, colleges expect students to honor their commitments unless there are compelling circumstances.

  • Valid Reasons for Withdrawal: These typically include severe financial issues, personal emergencies (like a serious illness), or other extenuating circumstances.

    If none of these reasons apply, the student may face penalties for cancellation, including losing their spot in the college admissions process entirely.

Acceptable Reasons for Canceling an Early Decision Commitment

Students need to understand that while backing out of an ED commitment is not ideal, certain reasons are deemed acceptable:

1. Financial Aid Issues: If the financial aid package becomes insufficient to cover the cost of attendance because a student’s financial situation has changed, students can appeal to the school’s admissions office.

2. Personal Circumstances: Serious family or personal matters, such as a family member’s illness, can warrant an ED cancellation.

When withdrawing from Early Decision, students should promptly contact the college admissions office, clearly explaining their situation and reason for the withdrawal; a polite and formal email detailing their reason for withdrawing is highly recommended. Keeping a record of this correspondence is crucial for future reference.

Advising Future Early Decision Applicants

The best way to prevent your clients from canceling an ED commitment is to educate them on Early Decision before they apply to help your students understand why ED is not always the best choice. 

If you have a client considering Early Decision, here are some key questions to ask and points to discuss with them before they submit their ED application:

1. Have they completed thorough research into their school of choice? Encourage your clients to research their choice school comprehensively, beyond academic offerings. Have they looked into campus culture and affordability? Have they taken the time to visit the campus in person and ask questions? Advise them to do so before they choose to apply through ED.

2. Have they considered other options? Discuss the differences between ED and other application options, like Early Action (EA), which allows for more flexibility if they change their minds, and Regular Decision (RD). After further consideration, they may find that ED is not their best option.

3. Do they understand the level of commitment? Emphasize the binding nature of ED applications and the importance of being 100% certain about their choice. There are consequences of backing out of ED that simply aren’t worth enduring; it’s vital that they fully grasp an ED commitment before applying.

Foster a reflective and informed decision-making process for your college-bound clients to help them feel more confident about their college application choices.

Withdrawing from an Early Decision (ED) application is not a decision to take lightly. By reminding your clients of their initial ED motivations, outlining the consequences of ED cancellations, and discussing acceptable reasons for Early Decision withdrawal, you can help them navigate this challenging situation with clarity.

Moreover, guiding future applicants to consider their commitment to Early Decision (ED) carefully before they apply can save them and their families unnecessary stress. As always, open communication and thorough preparation are key to successful college admissions experiences.

Related Posts:


Step into the Digital Age of SAT® Prep! 

The SAT® has made the switch to all-digital testing—and so has Clear Choice Prep

We’re ready to equip your tutoring business with top-tier, fully digital test-prep courses. Our white-label, all-digital, adaptive Digital SAT® practice tests come with accurate, algorithmic scoring, granting your tutors and students access to the vital data required for custom instruction and score enhancement. 

Ready to upgrade your test prep? Schedule a free demo and experience it yourself!